So did Andy Dalton and Cam Newton..oh right they are rookies!
The problem with Tebow isn’t that he needs time to evolve into the position. Tebow has never been a passer, his mechanics are awful an even though he has been told this since college he has done nothing to change it. Why do you think now he is going to get it right? I know he is a hard worker but throwing mechanics, unfortunately, are natural and if they are good they can be tweaked, but if poor, like Tebow’s, that road is going to be more than one offseason. The problem with your ‘great QB’s who started slow” argument is that the great ones all had great mechanics, grew up in passing offense in college, had great field vision, and the ability to read complex defenses and coverage – and it still took them a few years to get the hang of it! They were doing that since HS and college. Tebow is four to six years behind the curve as he has never been a pass first passer, who could read coverage and exploit it.
Look at Tebow’s mechanics and then go look back at any of the greats in their early years that I assume you are referencing like, Montana, Marino, Young, Elway, Mannings, Brady’s, and see the difference. Tebow is not close to them at that point in their careers and now he not only has to get his mechanics right he has to learn how to read the pass coverage that all the greats were learning since freshman year of college, or earlier in some cases. If there is one thing we can also say is that college success does not equate to pro success especially at the QB position.
The NFL is at a different level and the best quote I’ve heard about the transition from college to the NFL is this, “in college when the receiver is open he is open, and when he is covered he is covered, in the NFL when a receiver is covered he is covered and when he’s open, he’s covered.”
Lastly save the “Tebow’s a winner” BS!!! Most if not all players in the NFL are winners!!! Look at the bios of almost any starter, most were All-Everything in HS and College, in multiple sports, many played or had offers to play other sports in college and pro’s. Every guy in the league is basically the best of the best. Sure Tebow may have more college awards with the Nat’l Championships and the Heisman but that doesn’t make anyone else in the league less of a winner.