let’s do math 30k for a Toyota Camry probably got a 10k sign on for the car 6k after tax. So 24k for the car. Let’s assume you have that in the bank and pay in cash.
Assuming you drive 2500 miles a month you will get about $1,400 tax free rounded up to 17k a year.
Expenses will be gas at about $3,000(using $3 a gallon) a year. Insurance about a $1,000. Oil changes about $225. Tires will be about every 2 years so we will say $450 a year and other random maintenance at $400 a year. Total expenses $5,075
So all in said and done you will net about 12k per year. So after 2 years the car will be paid for. And a 30k car with an added 60k miles on will still be worth a decent amount of money so you have that value as well.
All in all I don’t believe you are losing money at all with this package unless you choose to drive an expensive car that doesn’t get great mileage or depreciates very fast. However, it does cause more stress and risk since you are responsible for the vehicle if something goes wrong. A plus is you get to choose what you drive.
There is going to be greatly varried levels of loss depending on 3 main factors, what fleet program you are coming from, what vehicle you choose to get, and how much driving is required for your territory (as well as how hard you work).
Some fleet programs put you in a nice mid to full size SUV fully loaded for as little as $50 a check, while others will put you in much less for a $250 a check.
Of course the vehicle you drive matters. Is a fully loaded Escalade is a silly choice? I think so, but I don't believe any moderately successful person wants to drive a Toyota Camry. Most specialty reps are used to driving well equipped 3 row SUVs.
What bothers me most about the low mileage reimbursement here, those with large difficult to manage territories who work the hardest take the biggest loss. There will be a break even point in miles driven per month for everyone where they start losing money per mile driven. Think you should head to one more office today or take a long drive to a potentially important customer tomorrow? Better think long and hard about if they will generate enough business from that visit that you can offset the expense that Sage isn't covering directly with additional bonus earned. They really need to rethink this system.
I can't buy gas here for anywhere close to $3 a gallon and I think your other estimates for cost are fairly low as well (although there are great differences per vehicle choice), not to mention you are forgetting things like brakes and other things, and what if major repairs may be needed? deductible because someone rear ends you? Etc etc..... Ask anyone who went from fleet vehicle to a job without one how many things they took for granted and how quickly unexpected expenses add up.
Do I think everyone working at Sage will lose money on their vehicle? No, but I think all good specialty reps coming from a decent fleet program who want to stick with a decent sized SUV will, unless they simply never drive. If I got the same exact fleet vehicle I am given now I estimate additional cost going to Sage to be minimum $10k a year, and maximum $20k a year, probably landing right in the middle, depending mostly on how much I drive. For this reason I passed on the job because when you start thinking about this and loss of other benefits good employers are giving, these "high" base salaries at Sage are really just normal. For my friends joining Sage they are hoping the company comes to their senses and implements a fleet program. I hope so for them, or at least up that per mileage reimbursement.
Good luck with the Toyota Camry.