Dr. Heilman
Guest
Dr. Heilman
Guest
Dr.Heliman- I think there is some misunderstanding regarding the amount of research that has been done on IgG supplementation (not colostrum). So much that I cannot post everything here. You will have to meet me half way and look at the research yourself. Please use these sources for said data.
#1 Effect of supplementation with multiple micronutrients (MMN) and/or bovine serum concentrate (BSC) on the growth of low-income, peri-urban Guatemalan (View Abstract)
KH Brown, MC Santizo, F Begin, B. Torun.
7/27/2004
#2 Acceptability, Safety, and Digestibility of Spray-Dried Bovine Serum Added to Diets of Recovering Malnourished Children (View Abstract)
Jorge L. Lembcke, Janet M. Peerson and Kenneth H. Brown
1/1/1997
#3 Cholesterol-lowering effect of skim milk from immunized cows in hypercholesterolemic patients (View Abstract)
Alain Golay, Jean-Marc Ferrara, Jean-Pierre Felber, and Heinz Schneider
7/20/2004
#4 Anti-inflammatory properties of human serum IgA: induction of IL-1 receptor antagonist and Fc-R(CD89)- medicated down-regulation of tumour necrosis fa (View Abstract)
H.M. wolf, I. Hauber, H. Gulle, A. Samstag, M.B Fischer, R.U. Ahmad and M.M. Eibl
7/14/2004
#5 Bovine colostrum: does it improve athletic performance? (View Abstract)
Jonathan D. Buckley
7/14/2004
#6 Evaluation of animal protein supplements in diets of early-weaned pigs (View Abstract)
J.A Hansen, J.L. Nelssen, R.D. Goodband, and T.L. Weeden
7/14/2004
#7 Plasma protein for pigs weaned at 19 to 24 days of age: effect on performance and plasma insulin-like growth factor I, growth hormone, insulin, and gl (View Abstract)
B.Z. de Rodas, K.S. Sohn, C.V. Maxwell, and L.J. Spicer
7/14/2004
#8 The Effects of Bovine Colostrum Supplementation on Body Composition and Exercise Performance in Active Men and Women (View Abstract)
Jose Antonio, Michael S. Sanders, and Darin Van Gammeren
7/14/2004
#9 Effect of bovine colostrum on anaerobic exercise performance and plasma insulin-like growth factor I (View Abstract)
Jonathan D. Buckley, Grant D. Brinkworth, and Marion J. Abbott
7/14/2004
#10 Use of spray-dried animal plasma in diets for weanling pigs (View Abstract)
Richard D. Coffey and Gary L. Cromwell
12/1/2001
#11 The Use of Bovine Serum Protein as an Oral Support Therapy Following Coronavirus Challenge in Calves (View Abstract)
J.D. Arthington, C.A. Jaynes, H.D. Tyler, S. Kaplis and J.D. Quigley, III
5/1/2002
#12 Oral Bovine Serum Concentrate Improves Cryptosporidial Enteritis in Calves (View Abstract)
Hunt, E. et al.
11/3/2002
#13 Dietary Plasma Protein Is Used More Efficiently than Extruded Soy Protein for Lean Tissue Growth in Early-Weaned Pigs (View Abstract)
Ruhong Jiang, Xiaoyan Chang, Barbara Stoll, Kenneth J. Ellis, Roman J. Shypallo, Eric Weaver, Joy Campbell and Douglas G. Burrin
3/1/2000
#14 N-Labeled Immunoglobulins from Bovine Colostrum Are Partially Resistant to Digestion in Human Intestine (View Abstract)
N. Roos, S. Mahe, R. Benamouzig, H. Sick, J. Rautureau and D. Tome
11/1/1995
I'll meet you more than half-way - I will shoot down 16 of your studies
Study #1 & #2....hmmm - adding protein to starving Guatemalan children. Okay I can't doubt that kids regarded as experiencing protein starvation may benefit from serum protein. I bet I would get the same effect with Albumin from eggs
#3 Cholesterol lowering effect - is it from having nutrient rich skim milk or from the IgG component?
#4 - IgA - NOT IgG
#5 - from protein - not IgG
#6, 7 - yes early weaned pigs use a lot of protein - not IgG from cows
#8, 9 - again - protein for athletes is important. So would albumin from eggs or lean meat
#10 - miss Piggy - again she likes Lots of protein - pigs have tremendous muscle bulk
#11, 12- - yes calves will benefit from cow colostrum and cow antibodies - calves are what cow colostrum is designed for
#13 - yes an animal based protein will have more complete amino acids which animals and humans use more than soy protein which lacks some amino acids.
#14 - hmmm cow immunoglobulins are resistant to human digestion????? doesn't this further prove my point.
For the sake of my time - I will address the other studies next week. Have a good weekend.