You would not have been eligible for presidents club, having only been in the territory for 5 months yet you were elligible for a 1? The whole rating and review process has been a major problem, is a major problem, and will always be a major problem. I am currently working with a law firm regarding this. I have recordings of managers at reviews literally stating that they didn't have any 3's so in certain competancies they had to give more 2's, because if they gave a certain amount of 3's (even though they were deserved) they would have to give a 3. The problem is the review is not based on your actual performance, it is based on a budget, and they have to fit all of us into this budget. This law firm believes this is unethical, corrupt, and illegal. I have been in contact with managers, 1 RD, and about ten reps ready to spill the beans. This firm believes the implications on career, pay, etc...are of a big enough scope that it will most likely go to a class action type of suit. Document everything. And yes the law firm stated that the recordings would most likely not be usable, however they were able to get a clear understanding of the problem, and how our career development, and pay is effected. I suggest all who have dealt with problem seek legal advise and document everything.m more to come...